An either-or troop choice for my son?

[EagleInKY]

Let your son decide, with your advice of course. It's really too hard to tell from your post. There's too much info that we don't have.

 

Just one comment about going "out of district" from a school pov. We have one scout that is in a different school district. He's never had an issue fitting in, even though he joined in with 10 boys who had been together for years in Cubs. The down side is when the troop schedules something that doesn't coincide with his school schedule. That can be a downer if he can't participate because of a different holiday schedule.