Redo partitial when MB requirements change?

[packsaddle]

Correct Eagledad, I was still fairly new to the troop at that time so I was watching from a distance, figuratively speaking. It was indeed a problem with the change of the Eagle requirements as you suggest. As far as I know, this was something communicated by the council. No one thought about taking it further...we were 'just following orders' at that time. But I remember thinking that this was just not fair to the scout. Fortunately, no one made a big deal about it. My point is that this HAS happened. But not with the merit badges, as again you noted.