ChanL

It is this Org chart that confused us. Org chart for small troop It puts "Troop Guide" on the same level as SPL and above ASPL.

Scout_A consider this is his last Summer Camp with Troop since he's almost Eagle and wish to make this summer camp a meaningful memory. However, if I understand correctly, ASPL should take SPL position when SPL is absent, regardless of his age, rank, experiences.

To answer your question, Scout_A consider this is his last Summer Camp with Troop since he's almost Eagle and wish to make this summer camp a meaningful memory.

The PL prefer Scout_A, but ScoutMaster think it should be Scout_B. I just want to know if there's any proper guideline to follow.

Hi, I have a question to ask regarding the chain of command in boy scouts. In this Summer Camp, we have two scouts want to be SPL of this Summer Camp. The current SPL didn't join Summer Camp. Scout_A: 15-years-old, been with Troop for 4 years, "Life" Rank, finished all Eagle requirements and scheduled Eagle BOR in next two weeks, finished NYLT, and served NYLT as staff. Current position = Troop Guide Scout_B: 13-years-old, been with Troop for 2 years. "Star" Rank, hasn't been to NYLT, but current position = Assistant Senor Patrol Leader. I found this from BSA's web site https://troopleader.scouting.org/troop-positions/ It's talking about the difference between Large Troop, and Small Troop. My question is, should Scout_B be the SPL of this Summer Camp, or the Scout_A? Is there a Scouts Leadership hierarchy that stated ASPL is higher than Troop Guide or vice versa? YIS, Chan

Hi, I have a question to ask regarding the chain of command in boy scouts. In this Summer Camp, we have two scouts want to be SPL of this Summer Camp. The current SPL didn't join Summer Camp. Scout_A: 15-years-old, been with Troop for 4 years, "Life" Rank, finished all Eagle requirements and scheduled Eagle BOR in next two weeks, finished NYLT, and served NYLT as staff. Current position = Troop Guide Scout_B: 13-years-old, been with Troop for 2 years. "Star" Rank, hasn't been to NYLT, but current position = Assistant Senor Patrol Leader. I found this from BSA's web site https://troopleader.scouting.org/troop-positions/ It's talking about the difference between Large Troop, and Small Troop. My question is, should Scout_B be the SPL of this Summer Camp, or the Scout_A? Is there a Scouts Leadership hierarchy that stated ASPL is higher than Troop Guide or vice versa? YIS, Chan