capeagle

Perhaps this problem with the calendar should be discussed with the parents of the scouts. Would it be possible for the PLC send a letter home with the boys in the troop (or mail/e-mail) them on whether or not they plan on allowing their boy attend certain meetings that fall on holidays? This would give the PLC an idea on whether or not to hold a meeting on that particular holiday. It may not solve the problem with the Troop Committee, but it might help schedule the meetings. If parents have no plans and there's a possibility a majority of the troop shows up, then have the meeting. Otherwise don't hold one. But that is the decision of the scouters as well as the scouts. Make sure you have enough leaders attending the meeting as well! What would happen if you held a meeting without the Committee's approval? Probably nothing but an unearned tounge-lashing!

I know this is kinda just rambling but I think this topic really needs to be addressed. I've always loved the line "We've always done it that way!". That should be a red light that something's not right! Scouting is supposed to be fun and educational at the same time. By adding more requirements to ranks/merit badges, it makes it harder for that scout to earn them. I really wish councils/districts/units would not interfere with the policies already dictated by national and let these boys have the opportunities they deserve. Whether it's how the Bobcat Badge is earned in Cubs or those going for their Eagle, there's already policies set forth in the national policies that direct scouts and scouters on how awards are earned. A scout in one area can receive a specific award when another scout who is of the same age/level can't. This doesn't make sense to me. Every Scout deserves those awards when the requirements are met through National's eyes, shouldn't be anyone else interfering with that! My suggestion for all these myths you hear (and if there's doubt): Ask to see it in writing from national!