InquisitiveScouter

@ScoutingMama4, welcome! This is totally acceptable. However, I believe she would need to get the Proposal approved by the Venturing Crew Unit Leader and Committee Chair. Where is she in the process? If her proposal has already been approved in the Troop, she should call the Council or District rep who signed it. (Hopefully this will be the District Advancement Chair or designee...) I recommend she seek guidance from them first, then get back to the Venturing Crew signatures on the proposal, if that is the way she is advised to go.

Actually, @swilliams, it would be ideal if your Scout posted it here, instead of you doing it for him. 😜

No, there isn't any explanation that does not reduce into the very behavior that those creating the group are trying to correct, stand up against, or bring attention to. On any form these days, for "Race" I select "Other" and write in "Human." Anywhere I can decline to enter "tribal" identifiers, I do. Every human being is unique. Therefore, there are almost 8 billion current groups to classify them into. (too many for my little old brain to keep track of.) Groups of one element 😜 But, as a mathematician, statistician, risk manager, observer of human behavior, and generally cogitating biped, I do use groups and categories to discriminate (and by that, I mean the un-hijacked definition of the word) with others, simply to conduct my daily life and stay alive.

Scouting is for adults as well. Some, with good intentions perhaps, go overboard and neglect the primacy of our mission to youth... but I have seen adults who really blossom in the program. Not all adults, when they join us, are "stellar" moral and ethical decision makers. By our example, through their training, and by exposing them to the eight methods (so, including the Oath and Law among other things), they become even more capable of delivering the promise to youth.

Why would you not leave this up to the Eagle Scout? It seems way out of line for adults (I seriously doubt any PLC would have the gall) to dictate such a thing. Whom an Eagle Scout wishes to recognize as her mentors is really none of the "Troop's" business. Is there any reasoning behind this you could share?

This will quickly go to spam 😜

Like the idea, but it looks too much like military then. BSA probably won't go for it.

1) National doesn't care 2) Yes, but I would love to wrong about this. 3) No, but I would love to wrong about this.

Things are looking up! Hey moderators! Could @swilliams post the GoFundMe here??

I spent many a day and night on both Green and Yellow ramps at Pope waiting for you guys to load up in my trusty C-141. Our airdrop speed was usually about 150 knots, depending on weight. If I was tail end Charlie of the formation, I'd slack off ten or 15 knots over the DZ to make your opening shock a little less. (Love what you did!!) Later did some DZ control there... Both my Dad and brother were 82nd... and I was born on Fort Campbell, and lived on Fort Bragg. Dad retired out of Fort Gordon. Both told me to go Air Force! (brother in Navy said the same!) Still have family in Raeford and Augusta. 😜 Airborne All the Way! (I trained for the nylon letdown, but was never daft enough to jump out of a perfectly good airplane 😜 )

Careful! You'll be put on the IVF!!

Deleted...

Try this... see NNJC entry https://www.facebook.com/search/top/?q=Cub Scout Adventures and Requirements or here, I converted it to a pdf for you... CS Adv & Req.pdf

Totally agree... These concepts seem a little inappropriate for the age groups...

Is there a PTA that works with the DoDDS there? Maybe they elect somebody... Or could they talk with the SPL of the Scout Troop? It does say "someone who is elected"

Only on Minecraft or Fortnite 😜 With "requirements" like those, I think they lost sight of the fun aspect of anything and everything.

@cctroop123, welcome! I'm not getting a link there... Let's try this: http://scoutmaster.org/boy led troop.pdf

BTW, the Newspeak on this is "Range and Target Sports" (RATS?) watch for the change to creep in over time. https://www.ncacbsa.org/shooting-sports/

LOL, what clothing manufacturer is in USA that would fit the bill?

I would ROCK these! LOL

No, time for a Carhartt x BSA collab 😜 \ https://www.carhartt.com/ REI is kind of bougie... (REI member since 1989.)

Will any of their achievements be on the shirt? Or is it all just organizational stuff...??

Here's an example... JTE patches... change every year, if you wear them... (Yes, shirt is well-worn, and has seen many better days 😜 )

LOL, Badge Magic destroys fabric 😜

Ugh... why doesn't National get with the program and use velcro!? Adding velcro to uniforms and patches makes things lighter than metal and more easily interchangeable. I believe it would be a cheaper alternative than metal awards and insignia... and could possibly be sourced from recycled materials. Production of metal gadgets with paints and coatings seems less eco-friendly, but I reserve the right to be wrong.