Another longtime lurker but wanted to contribute to the conversation from a LDS scouter's perspective.
I've been involved in Scouting for going on 30 years. For the last four years I've been serving as a Scoutmaster.
From my experience and perspective, CalicoPenn hit it on the head. The programs have underserved the young men in the 14-18 age range. Yes, there's a financial consideration but this move has been a longtime coming and there were discussions on a local level about changes that I can remember having in the 90's. The reality is that they haven't worked due to a large number of reasons, predominately organizationally at the local LDS level. These challenges have been discussed ad nauseam. I do take the Church's statement at face value as my experience aligns to the picture they painted. I don't believe that these changes are a result of the recent political discourse, however I'm sure it hastened the review and considerations.
I firmly believe that the decision was made in the best interest of the young men. The fact that they are sticking with the program for the younger boys is encouraging and telling. All this being said, there's a part of me that is sadden by the change. Having been a member of a high-functioning Venture Crew in my youth (earned the Silver and Ranger awards), I know firsthand the value that these programs can offer to young men when properly executed. The problem again has always been consistency, leadership and support.
