As I am reading through these posts I'm alarmed that some units are treating BOR like they are military promotion boards. ready for the promotion boards. I had to march into the room, stand at attention, salute,and repeat the NCO creed. All of this before I was asked a single question to be considered for promotion. I was an adult, nervous and afraid. I can't imagine how a 11 - 17 year old kid would feel doing something similar to this for a BOR. I sat on about 10 BOR in the past few years. The scouts come into the room and he either joins us at the table or sit with us on comfortable sofa and chairs and we have a casual conversation with the scouts. Questions are asked about how he feels about the troop, his patrol, what's going good, what's going bad, etc. There's no retest. They are asked what meal did they cook for this rank or what or who did you teach with the EDGE method. The questions vary on the rank and age of the scout. It is not an inquisition and it is not an easy check off either.