Ahhh... a thread after my own heart. I make the neckers for our Troop to pretty traditional specs and I'm firmly in the tuck-the-collar-inside-and-wear-the-necker-on-the-outside camp. However I freely admit to being in a minority of one in our BSA Troop. Having said that they probably think it's simply British eccentricity at play, along with the occasional pith helmet appearance and campaign hat with the dimples turned 45 degrees. I admit I have also contemplated taking a pair of scissors to one of my shirt collars as someone mentioned earlier ("Elvis" - haha yes!)...
Funnily enough, for all the talk of boys not wanting to wear neckers, we've just started a new Venture Crew and the lads have unanimously voted to wear a necker, despite the current lack of uniform requirements. That really does give me hope for our youth.
Coracle