Thank you for your sentiments. The really frustrating thing about our particular situation is that we could have it all. Build a new utilitarian kitchen and rest rooms off the back corner and keep the historic lodge, the beautiful main hall so many have occupied over the last 83 years, intact. In addition, the BSA could gain a lot of respect from the local community that does not want to see this historical landmark demolished.
We are still actively searching for other old Boy Scout camp lodges/dining halls. The more we look, the more special and unique our Finch Lodge appears to be. We have found a couple of less grand Scout Lodges but neither is currently operated by BSA. One is now part of a state park in Wyoming. The other, in Chahalis, Wa, was built in 1938 by WPA as a shared community and Boy Scout center. Never really a camp lodge. We have been told that there is a 1950's vintage, architect designed dining hall, "Coral Rock Dining Hall" at Ben Delatour Scout Ranch in Colorado. That council had the vision to renovate it a few years ago, including a state-of-the-art kitchen.
There may be other great lodges out there that are not represented on the WEB. We'd like to know about them.