I have a 17 year old scout who would like to return after over 2 years absence. He left as a Life scout, short only 2 MBs and a project for his Eagle. His absence began following an incident with an asst. scoutmaster ~ neither one was completely right or wrong, but both the scout and his parents were quite upset about some judgemental remarks that were made. Subsequently, the scout's school life got very demanding and the two issues combined contributed to his prolonged absence. Some members of the committe are reluctant to welcome him back, their feelings being to allow his return after so long an absence to finish his eagle would dilute the award in the eyes of the other troop members who have maintained continous attendance and supported the troop program. I know basic philosophy is do what's best for the boy and I would hate to see his earlier work go to waste, but I also don't want to discourage our more dedicated members. Any info on policy or advice would be greatly appreciated, I'll need some good references to convince the committee & scoutmasters. Thank You