My troop, whether meant to be so or not, has added several "requirements" to the Eagle Scout badge. NO ONE in my troop gets Eagle under the age of 16, because as part of our program, you need to take a JLT course or be a counselor in training at a Boy Scout summer camp (neither of which occurs if you are under fourteen). Also, you must attend at least 3/4 of the meetings to be considered to advance a rank. Leadership does not carry over, so if you didn't show up for a month, you start anew. In addition, none of the projects are to be under 250 hours labor. Our troop has the best reputation of any in the county for this reason. We do our projects well (over and above working-grade) and they are always the kind of project you can point at twenty or so years down the line because they will still be there. Our troop also applies the JLT, 15-year-old policy to Order of the Arrow as well, and, sadly, our boys have been the oldest Ordeal members at our lodge's fall conference for many years. This summer, while on staff at a camp, there was a week where almost a quarter of camp got tapped out, and five of the boys were FIRST-YEAR-CAMPERS. Here's my few cents on the issue.