I'm VERY new to this forum, and let me admit I mostly skimmed the answers before I started typing mine, but I am firmly of the opinion that the uniform is what MAKES the scout a SCOUT. Otherwise, as noted previously, a Pack of Cub Scouts or a Troop of Boy Scouts becomes yet another uncontrolled mob of boys.
We had the question come up recently amongst our Pack, particularly among Tiger Cub parents, because it was a "hassle" to get the boys to wear their uniforms. Another leader and I were discussing that particular comment just this morning, and we were of the opinion that maybe it IS a little much for a first-grader, but maybe not so much for Wolf, Bear or Webelos Scouts.
I can see the argument for starting early in getting the boys into the habit of wearing the uniform, but I think our Pack may be on the verge of making it optional for Tiger Cubs. I don't have a vote as my son is graduating to Boy Scouts this month.
My opinion, and that of the other leader I talked to, is that it's only a hindrance to those boys (and parents) whose enthusiasm for the program is cooling some. My "hardcore" Cub Scouts are in full uniform at every meeting, proudly showing off their badges and the activity patches covering their bragging vests. I believe seeing this pride in uniform inspires the younger boys to do the same, making it a self-sustaining reaction.
The Boy Scout Troop we are moving to requires the FULL uniform (including pants) at Troop Meetings, but does allow exceptions when a boy is coming straight from another activity (such as baseball or football) but still wants to participate with his Troop. I believe this strikes a fair balance between the scouting program and other activities.
Scott Armstrong
Pack 2, Suwannee River Area Council
http://nfcscouts.tripod.com
