Thanks for all your suggestions. Perhaps I should make myself more clear. Yes, we do ask each Scout at a Board of Review and SM Conference what they like about the troop, its programming, what they'd do differently, etc. And yes our older boys go through the troop program planning process each August.
What I'd like is some sort of end of the program year quantitative analysis of what was a "hit" and what was a "dud."
I've never attended a corporate training session (or Scouting one, for that matter) that I didn't have to fill out an evaluation sheet at the end of the program. This provides valuable information to the presenter in an anonymous manner. Young Scouts may be hesitant to voice their true feelings in face-to-face meetings with adults.
Is anyone doing anything like this on paper? Maybe listing 20 to 30 activities and asking all the boys in the troop to rank their top 10 choices? Or listing all camp-out activities from the previous year and asking them to rank them on a 1-10 scale with 10 being "Super!" and 1 being "deadly dull"?
Thanks for all the feedback. Hope you all have a great start to your '09-'10 Scouting year!