JASMtroop131

I am posting this message for my scout master who has raised this question. He is not overly computer literate so he had me post this to give him a second opinion. The scoutmaster, other adult leaders, as well as fellow scouts have raised this issue. He is the patrol leader. He is a wrestler and has pinned kids to the ground on many occasions during troop events, but the adults are aware of this. This issue has been raised with him and his parents. We are seeking an opinion on any or all parts of or both these requirements.

Hello I am trying to solicit everyones opinion on this. All comments are welcome. Their is a kid in my troop that is trying to get the six months leadership time to earn life. Here is an outline of what he has done in these six months. He has attended 1 out of 3 campouts. He has attended 2 of the 4 patrol leader's council meetings. (What we call our meeting where all the youth leaders get together and plan for the troop) Of these 2 meetings he was very negative at one of them. He tends to be physically rough with the younger boys of the troop. His communications skills as his patrols leader have been below average. Do you think he qualifies for the requirement to displaying scout spirit and acting in a position of leadership for 6 months? Junior Assistant Scout Master Troop 131 Old Colony Council