Why join an organization that wants to be about religion and the outdoors and leadership, swear to uphold the values, grab the highest honor, and then say, "Guess what. I lied. I don't believe in anything."
The Boy Scouts have the right to assemble, to define core beliefs, and to ask that people who join share their beliefs.
It's like joining the Catholic Church, then starting an abortion clinic, then crying "not fair" if the local parish called you on it.
Or: It's like being elected President. Then saying,
"Oh, by the way. I don't really believe in the constitution. I'm a communist. What? You want me to resign? Wah. Not fair."
This kid is not an Eagle in my book. He's a deceptive, confused, misguided kid. And another thing: he'd rather whine than say, "I love Scouting but I don't honestly believe what I stood up and swore I did. So the only honorable thing for me to do is return the badge."
Instead he's on Fox News getting attention for saying how unfair it is that he's getting booted.
Leslie