I've been trying to get more information on CS2010 since I heard about it and still the information is vague at best. "No more themes" and "Den based advancement" is all I'm seeing. As a Tiger Den Leader, I've been following Program Helps since the beginning. My boys all got their Bobacat and Immediate Recognition Emblem after the first month and they all got their Tiger badge in February. I don't see how people following the Program Helps can't do the same. Sure, I switched out some crafts or games here and there or blended Den Meetings when we had a holiday that might make 2 Den Meetings a month hard, but we did it. And it wasn't difficult. I listed the month, meeting dates, theme, and Go See It then had each Tiger/Adult Partner team sign up for one and they did everything for that month!
Which brings me to my little vent about the problem. I didn't even know about Program Helps until I did Leader Specific Training, a full month after we were recruited and I registered as Den Leader. Three months later, I was at a Pack event talking to one of my Tiger parents and I pulled out Program Helps to reference something. The Wolf Den Leader was nearby and came over asking about the book. Next thing I know I'm *introducing* Program Helps to not just the Wolf Den Leader but the Bear Den Leader too! Turns out the Cubmaster never told them about it, they never heard about it in training, and they had been struggling to come up with Den activities for YEARS! So National can make all the changes to the program that they want, but if it doesn't get communicated to the Den Leaders, it's not going to matter. I keep running into this problem with other units (I'm also the Cub Scout Roundtable Commissioner). The flow of information from one "generation" of leaders to the next is almost non-existent. Until that changes, it's not going to matter how they tweak the program, there will still be great Den Leaders who advance their boys and make the program fun and there will be not-so-great Den Leaders who just squeak by on their own.