evmori

Handle it the same way all other SMC's are handled.

I have never heard of appeals lasting this long! There must be something holding this up.

I do know midsummer started posting this in another forum before she showed up here. There is something more to this story than we know and I would bet there never was an appeal.

Where was the ACLU float?

Don't recharter them!

I thought it was great!

I'd go with what the Handbook states.

HICO, bull! This is important. I'm gonna bet the appeal was turned down if there was ever an appeal. Happy New Year.

I think the answer is maybe.

I never expected anything to happen! But it would be nice if the person who led us on this merry chase would update us.

Well wouldn't POR be applicable to all adult leadership positions?

Well one more day in 2009! Usually no news is good news but in this case no news just doubts the validity of the situation!

While both the VFW and American Legion are very religiously conservative, neither one appears to exclude atheists. The VFW removed their "believe in god" requirement about 5 years ago. What does that have to do with the topic of this thread? Absolutely nothing!

Coulda been a PEBKAC error!

It appears this situation mdsummer45 describes has been going on for a year! There is really something fishy about this whole thing. I am seriously beginning to doubt if National ever had this for appeal or even if an appeal was ever filed! I'm starting to think BadenP is correct that mdsummer45 is an attention junkie!

I would agree BadenP except for one thing - mdsummer45 posted the exact same story in another forum prior to posting here. There is no way National would take so long on this UNLESS there is something that falls in the gray area of acceptable behavior.

You could be correct pack, but that's how I do it! We use the most current MB pamphlet! If I'm completing a partial, I check the start date and use the most current pamphlet regardless of what the Scout used.

Good question. I would say it is up to the counselor. This is what I would do. I would count the requirements completed under the old requirements as completed and go with the new requirements for the unfinished ones.

There are 11 days left in this month and tow of them are on the weekend and one is Christmas. Still no news???

Beavah is correct. The G2SS states not to convoy. Big difference.

Now that is living the Scout Oath & Law in your everyday life!

The moderators are noted by a * beside their forum status.

There are good & bad things about caravaning. I personally feel caravaning is a good thing! The entire group can stay together. Naturally every vehicle has directions. This will help eliminate the need to stay too close together.

I think what the BSA did was the exact correct thing to do! She was caught apparently in the act! Have a nice day!

Ketchup just kills the taste of everything you put it on!