Jump to content

Forums

  1. Welcome to SCOUTER Forum

    1. New to the Forum?

      Tell us a bit about yourself so we can welcome you to the Virtual Roundtable

      7.7k
      posts
    2. Forum Support & Announcements

      Forum support and announcements from SCOUTER.com

      2.7k
      posts
    3. New to Scouting?

      Questions and answers for parents and leaders new to Scouting.

      3.4k
      posts
  2. Open Discussion - Program

    1. 153.6k
      posts
  3. News & Politics

    1. Issues & Politics

      In answer to many requests, we established a separate forum for these topics. Those not interested can skip this forum instead of spending time reading unwanted messages to identify content.

      124.4k
      posts
  4. Unit Fundraising

    1. Unit Fundraising

      Ideas for fundraising projects and programs for your unit.

      6.5k
      posts
  5. Order of the Arrow

    1. Order of the Arrow

      Discussions for OA Members and those interested in Scouting's Honor Society. Also includes a private sub-forum for OA Members only.

      10.3k
      posts
  6. The Patrol Method

    1. The Patrol Method

      Lessons and questions of Scout leadership and operating troop program

      16.7k
      posts
  7. Cub Scouts

    1. Cub Scouts

      For Cub Scout specific topics only.

      46.9k
      posts
  8. Wood Badge and Adult Leader Training

    1. Wood Badge and adult leader training

      Post Wood Badge specific topics here.

      19.2k
      posts
  9. Advancement Resources

    1. Advancement Resources

      Scouting ranks, merit bades, and the advancement programs

      47.3k
      posts
  10. Patch Trading Central

    1. Patch Trading Central

      Have a patch or memorabilia you're looking to swap? Use this virtual patch trading blanket. (This area is intended to facilitate memorabilia swapping, not necessarily commerce.)

      1.6k
      posts
  11. Working with Kids

    1. Working with Kids

      Counseling, inspiring and teaching kids.

      12.5k
      posts
  12. Uniforms

    1. Uniforms

      For All messages dealing with Scout Uniforms

      30.6k
      posts
  13. Camping & High Adventure

    1. 28.4k
      posts
  14. Girl Scouting

    1. Girl Scouting

      Content specifically related to Girl Scouting

      2.8k
      posts
  15. Summer Camp

    1. Summer Camp

      All about planning and going to Summer Camp

      10.7k
      posts
  16. Scouting Around the World

    1. Scouting Around the World

      Scouting is a worldwide Movement with nearly 30 million members in 151 countries around the world.

      1.6k
      posts
  17. Council Relations

    1. Council Relations

      Discuss issues relating to Scout Councils, districts and working with professionals

      11.3k
      posts
  18. Venturing Program

    1. Venturing Program

      Meet people from other Venture Crews and discuss program.

      6.6k
      posts
  19. Scouting History

    1. Scouting History

      Share and celebrate the history of the world's largest youth Movement

      3.4k
      posts
  20. Scouting the Web

    1. Scouting the Web

      Share tips and info for Scouting webmasters and discuss Scouting resources on the web

      1.6k
      posts
  21. Scoutmaster Minutes

    1. Scoutmaster Minutes

      Inspirational stories and meaningful remarks to share

      1.3k
      posts
  • Latest Posts

    • Don't disagree with you on when they could have messaged. Does seem to be desired to use NAM as the showcase the past few years- but that could be self-serving trying to get more people to attend ((BSA makes $ off the registration fees for NAM).
    • Maybe I'm just overly cynical, but that sounds like someone in your council fighting the success. It could just be poor job performance, of course. But the kind of stiff, emotional resistance to girls and women being a full, authentic part of Scouting America that some people in the organization have doesn't just evaporate in a year or even in the face of evidence. For them, it's not about success for the organization, it's about forcing the world to be a certain way. In this case cooties-free. It could definitely be that your council's policy is a result of an internal struggle between people who wanted coed and people who didn't. Did you see Scouting Maverick's take on postponing coed in Scouts BSA earlier?  https://scoutingmaverick.com/2025/01/21/celebrating-a-sexist-scam-linked-troop-wood-badge-highlights-sas-cultural-rot/ Your example of a CC who is so invested in no girls that he's going to de facto let his unit die rather than go coed isn't the only one I'm sure. Actually, you mentioned several such units, so... They're going to keep shrieking until it stops working, which seems to be roundabout now or soon. But some won't stop shrieking because they realized it's actually fine, they will still sabotage what they can. Meanwhile in my corner of my female-friendly council, many leaders are working together to build out a coed pipeline from Cub Scouts into Scouts BSA. Not coincidentally we're about equal numbers of men and women. And it's working - all of our units are growing. If we keep working, Scouting America is going to come back from cultural oblivion in a decade or so.  
    • That's exactly where we are right now.  Most of the adults in the troop were not Scouts.  They took the youth lead concept to an extreme and now we have a patient that is sick.  I'm trying to avoid getting to the life support stage, much less CPR.  The oldest Scouts have succumbed to sports and the fumes.  Half the troop is under the age of 13 and a quarter is under the age of 12.  We are going to have to actually teach the PLC, such that it is, how to do the skills and then get them to retain the information long enough to teach it to their patrols.  
    • I get what you're saying; I would counter though that national should have been able to see that and should have planned that timeline to release the coed program earlier. So right now female membership growth is significantly outpacing male membership growth (I think the NAM numbers were 3x the number of females are joining right now), and most of us have no where to send our female AOLs.  I don't know about you guys but my council adopted the dumbest policy during the coed pilot. Only existing linked units from prior to the coed policy can be coed, so we have female AOLs just dropping from the program. Who could be so stupid to think retention of female scout was going to go up in some of these councils where we're stuck telling parents that if they want to keep their daughters in the program they will have to continue to drive an additional 10+ miles just to go to a troop meeting when their sons are swinging around the block for a meeting? 
    • So we have a framework right. It's clear that adult leaders have to step in and instruct the senior scouts when there is a knowledge gap or lack of retention. This goes back to BP and his original Aids to Scoutmastership. The program has always allowed for adult leaders to step in; how we step in is critical though. My advice, which I would say is backed up by the solid century+ of the program and going back to the root (BP) is, in the absence of capable elected youth leaders, adults step in to teach those youth leaders and get them to the point where they are capable.  In short it's a 2 part solution. Part 1) Adults are on hand and always willing to teach the PLC members what they need to do to teach, mentor, and lead the rest of the troop. Part 2) Constantly assessing if you're not being a lazy  fat slob by flopping on the phrase "Have you asked your SPL".
  • Recent Status Updates

  • Popular Contributors

  • Who's Online (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...